Shohei Ohtani Says the Root Cause Is Still Unclear—But He’ll Hit in the NLDS
The Los Angeles Dodgers will have Shohei Ohtani in the batter’s box when their National League Division Series begins Saturday, Oct. 3. What they will not have is the full two-way version of baseball’s biggest star—or even a complete answer for what has been bothering him.
Ohtani acknowledged Friday that he has not identified the root cause of the physical problems that interrupted his season. The four-time Most Valuable Player is managing lingering trouble involving his right biceps and left knee, while Associated Press reporting also identified a neck issue. The uncertainty will carry directly into the Dodgers’ best-of-five matchup with the Atlanta Braves.
He can hit, but he will not pitch
Los Angeles expects Ohtani to remain in the lineup as its designated hitter. He has already been ruled out from pitching in the postseason and has not appeared on the mound since July 3, according to Reuters.
That distinction matters because Ohtani had been one of the sport’s most valuable pitchers before his season changed. He finished his abbreviated pitching campaign 8-2 with a 1.79 ERA, 95 strikeouts and 26 walks in 85 2/3 innings. The Dodgers will now ask him to influence October from one side of the game only.
Ohtani said the deeper medical review will likely wait until the offseason. For now, the task is management: reduce the discomfort, keep his swing functional and get through a postseason in which Los Angeles is pursuing a third consecutive World Series title.
The numbers show why the uncertainty matters
Ohtani spent time on the 15-day injured list in September because of the biceps and knee problems. He returned with only five regular-season games remaining and went 5-for-21, a .238 average, with one double, one walk, eight strikeouts and one RBI.
The larger late-season trend was more concerning. Over his final 18 games as a designated hitter, Ohtani was 11-for-70—just .157—with no home runs and one RBI. MLB.com reported that the injuries and an attempted pitching ramp-up coincided with a prolonged slump, leaving the Dodgers unsure exactly what version of their superstar will appear in October.
His full-season batting line still reflects elite production: a .275 average, .377 on-base percentage and .512 slugging percentage, with 30 home runs and 81 RBIs in 139 games. But postseason series can turn on a handful of plate appearances, and recent form matters more when there is little recovery time between games.
The Dodgers are betting on rest and repetition
Ohtani used the Dodgers’ first-round bye to rest and rebuild his timing. His work included simulated at-bats against teammates and a pitching machine. He also faced Yoshinobu Yamamoto in live batting practice, an unusual test against one of the club’s top pitchers.
Dodgers manager Dave Roberts has been candid that Ohtani is not at full strength, while still expecting him to be ready for the lineup. The club’s confidence rests less on a guarantee of peak production than on Ohtani’s ability to adapt quickly once the intensity and pitch sequencing of a real playoff game return.
That creates a narrow but compelling question for Game 1: can Ohtani’s talent overcome limited game action and unresolved physical problems before Atlanta’s pitchers find a way to exploit them?
A high-stakes opener in Los Angeles
The Dodgers will start left-hander Tarik Skubal in Game 1. Los Angeles acquired the two-time reigning American League Cy Young Award winner from Detroit on Aug. 2, and he went 5-2 with a 2.61 ERA in 10 starts for the Dodgers, Reuters reported.
Atlanta arrives with its own pitching uncertainty after surviving a three-game Wild Card Series. The Braves used ace Chris Sale on short rest to close their clinching win Thursday, while starters Martín Pérez and Bryce Elder have been ruled out for the NLDS. That could place even more pressure on the Braves’ bullpen—and give Ohtani several different matchups to solve.
The Dodgers do not need Ohtani to pitch to change the series. They do need his bat to look closer to its season-long standard than its September version. Until the first pitch, that remains October’s biggest unknown in Los Angeles.
Sources: Reuters, The Associated Press, MLB.com and Reuters’ Game 1 report.