Trump Fired Seattle’s U.S. Attorney in Under an Hour—A Judge Put Him Back
Roger Rogoff’s first turn as Seattle’s top federal prosecutor lasted less than an hour. His second began with a federal judge telling the Trump administration that the president could not erase a court appointment on his own.
On Thursday, October 1, U.S. District Judge Stanley Bastian provisionally restored Rogoff as U.S. attorney for the Western District of Washington. The ruling blocks the administration from treating anyone else as the district’s top prosecutor or denying Rogoff the resources needed to perform the job while the case continues.
The decision creates a consequential test of presidential power, judicial authority and the Senate’s confirmation role. It is also the first reported legal victory by a court-appointed U.S. attorney removed during the administration’s broader struggle with federal judges over who may lead powerful prosecutor offices.
Fired less than an hour after taking the oath
The district’s 17 active and senior judges unanimously selected Rogoff in July after the office remained without a Senate-confirmed leader. A former prosecutor and state judge, he took the oath on July 15.
Less than an hour later, the Trump administration informed him that the president had removed him. Rogoff sued, arguing that a court-appointed U.S. attorney may remain in office until the Senate confirms a presidential nominee.
Reuters reported that Bastian concluded Congress did not give the president unilateral power to remove a prosecutor appointed by a district court. The Associated Press independently confirmed the reinstatement, the less-than-an-hour timeline and the Justice Department’s plan to appeal.
Why judges appointed Rogoff
Presidents ordinarily nominate U.S. attorneys, who then require Senate confirmation. Federal law also gives the attorney general power to install an interim prosecutor, but that appointment generally lasts 120 days. If no confirmed replacement is in place when that period ends, the district court may appoint someone to serve until the vacancy is filled.
Seattle’s office had not had a Senate-confirmed leader since 2023. Charles Neil Floyd, a former immigration judge, began serving as interim U.S. attorney in October 2025, but the administration did not send his nomination to the Senate. Judges later exercised their vacancy authority and chose Rogoff.
The White House subsequently nominated Pete Serrano for the position. That nomination does not itself place Serrano in the office; the Senate must confirm him before he becomes the permanent U.S. attorney.
The judge’s ruling is preliminary—but immediate
Bastian granted a preliminary injunction, meaning the ruling controls who holds the office while Rogoff’s lawsuit proceeds. It is not the final judgment in the case, and an appeals court could pause or reverse it.
For now, however, the order recognizes Rogoff as the rightful officeholder from the moment he was sworn in. It also bars the administration from blocking his access to the responsibilities, benefits and resources of the position.
The Justice Department said it disagrees with the ruling, intends to seek an immediate stay and will appeal. The dispute therefore could move quickly into higher federal courts.
One office, but a national separation-of-powers fight
U.S. attorneys decide which federal cases their offices pursue, supervise criminal prosecutions and represent the federal government in civil litigation. The Western District of Washington’s office employs approximately 85 attorneys and 70 support staff, according to Reuters.
The conflict is bigger than Seattle. The administration has removed or challenged court-selected prosecutors in New York, New Jersey and Virginia as it seeks greater control over federal law-enforcement leadership. Rogoff appears to be the first dismissed court appointee to sue and win provisional reinstatement.
The constitutional tension is straightforward: the president has the power to nominate, the Senate has the power to confirm, and Congress has authorized courts to prevent an office from remaining vacant when those branches have not completed the process. If a president can immediately fire the court’s temporary choice without securing Senate approval for a replacement, that statutory backstop may have little practical force.
What happens next
The administration’s requested stay will be the first major test. If granted, Rogoff could again be sidelined while the appeal proceeds. If denied, he remains in charge unless the Senate confirms a permanent successor or a higher court intervenes.
That leaves Seattle’s prosecutor office with an unusually public question hanging over it: not simply who leads, but which branch of government gets the final word when the normal appointment process stalls.