Trump’s Rush to Confirm Judges Hits Republican Roadblocks
President Donald Trump’s drive to confirm as many federal judges as possible before Democrats take control of the Senate is encountering an unexpected obstacle: resistance from members of his own party.
Republicans have confirmed 57 judicial nominees during Trump’s second term, but several GOP senators are now blocking or questioning candidates chosen for courts in their home states. The dispute is unfolding during the lame-duck session, when Senate leaders have only a short window to move lifetime appointments through the confirmation process.
Republican senators push back
Reuters reported Sunday that Sens. John Cornyn of Texas, Thom Tillis of North Carolina and Alan Armstrong of Oklahoma have raised objections or helped slow nominations. Their complaints center on the White House’s selection process and whether senators received sufficient input on judges serving their states.
The conflict involves a Senate tradition known as the “blue slip.” Home-state senators return the form to signal support for a district-court nominee. Withholding it can prevent a nominee from receiving a Judiciary Committee hearing. Although it is not a law, the custom gives individual senators considerable influence over federal trial-court appointments.
Cornyn has not committed to supporting T. Elliot Gaiser, the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel chief who was nominated for a federal judgeship in Dallas. Reuters reported that Gaiser was selected without going through Texas’s usual senator-led screening process. Without Cornyn’s blue slip, the nomination may not advance to its scheduled committee hearing.
Tillis is also supporting Armstrong’s opposition to Zach West, an Oklahoma attorney praised by conservative legal activists. Armstrong initially backed West but later withdrew his support. That left the nominee without enough committee votes to move forward, at least temporarily.
White House replaced an Arkansas nominee
The most visible sign of the dispute came in Arkansas. The White House withdrew U.S. District Judge Lee Rudofsky’s nomination to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals after Republican Sens. John Boozman and Tom Cotton declined to support him. Trump then nominated Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland for the same vacancy.
The substitution is documented in the White House’s Nov. 10 submission to the Senate. The Associated Press also reported that Cornyn and Tillis were prepared to oppose Rudofsky after Arkansas’s senators objected to his selection.
The disagreement does not reflect broad Republican opposition to Trump’s judicial agenda. GOP leaders continue to describe confirmations as a priority, and the Senate confirmed another district judge Thursday. Instead, the fight shows how disputes over consultation and Senate prerogatives can disrupt even nominations from a president whose party controls the chamber.
A shrinking window for 23 nominees
Twenty-three judicial nominees remained pending as the confirmation push entered its final weeks, according to Reuters. Senate Majority Leader John Thune has said judicial appointments are a priority while Republicans retain control.
The Senate Judiciary Committee’s public docket shows multiple nominations awaiting hearings, committee action or floor votes. Colorado-based U.S. District Judge Daniel Domenico’s nomination to the 10th Circuit is scheduled for Senate action Monday, while other nominees face tighter procedural or political hurdles.
Federal judges receive lifetime appointments, so confirmations can shape the law long after a president leaves office. Trump appointed 234 judges during his first term, including three Supreme Court justices. Reuters estimates that roughly one-third of active federal judges are now Trump appointees.
The White House says it expects all pending nominees to be confirmed this year. Whether that happens may depend not only on Democratic opposition but also on whether the administration can resolve its disagreements with Republican senators before control of the Senate changes hands.
Featured image: editorial illustration.